appraisive

It is safe to say that throughout its history “beautiful” has always embodied both descriptive and appraisive elements: it has been used both to characterize works of art or nature and to judge them.

Dictionary of the History of Ideas MONROE C. BEARDSLEY 1968

She had risen to meet him by the time he had mounted the steps, and he knew that her first glance was appraisive.

The Price Francis Lynde 1893

So much the president was able to note in the appraisive glance -- and to remember afterward.

The Price Francis Lynde 1893

The portly thief-taker leaned back in his chair and regarded me with a coldly appraisive eye.

Branded Francis Lynde 1893