hurdat

We gave our comments to Landsea et al. last Aug. to be considered by the hurdat committee.

Holland and Webster Figure 1 « Climate Audit 2006

The Belanger/Jelinek comments submitted to hurdat identified tons of these kinds of discrepancies.

Holland and Webster Figure 1 « Climate Audit 2006

From list of comments submitted to hurdat, but no response as of yet, an example:

Holland and Webster Figure 1 « Climate Audit 2006

To my knowledge, people like Emanuel, Webster use the hurdat files and, so even if you think that these files include extratropical storms, surely this is what has entered into the present discourse and it’s not up to me to try to segregate things.

YTD Hurricane Activity « Climate Audit 2007

But it’s pointless for me to try to sort out what should and shouldn’t be in the hurdat dataset if the originators haven’t.

YTD Hurricane Activity « Climate Audit 2007